Intelligence and state security officers who left Soviet serviceCompiled by Kevin Riehle

Entry 15 of 121 · revised 2026-11-22

Fedor Pavlovich Drugov

Known asLeonard Benar

Федор Павлович Другов

Biography

Being present at the birth of the ChK, Fedor Pavlovich Drugov was witness to the foundational discussions about establishing an intelligence and security function within the new Bolshevik regime. Those discussions planted the seeds of doubt that later prompted his defection. However, he eventually even doubted his doubts, which led to his voluntary return to the Soviet Union, where he was arrested and executed.

Drugov was born 17 June 1891 in St. Petersburg. His father was a printer, and Drugov himself worked for a time as an apprentice under his father. He became active in radical anarchist maximalist activities and participated in anti-tsarist violence in 1905 at the age of 14. He continued his anarchist activities, leading to his arrest in March 1909 and sentencing to execution, although the sentence was reduced to 1 1/2 years incarceration because of his young age. He was arrested again in August 1911 and exiled to Siberia for 3 years, where he became acquainted with other revolutionaries with whom he later participated in the October revolution.[i] His dedication to the anarchist-revolutionary philosophy was eventually to place him at odds with the Bolsheviks.[ii]

He returned to St. Petersburg in 1914 and was mobilized as a private in the Imperial Russian Army during the summer of 1915, and the following year his unit served on the front. He was elected from his unit as a SR representative to the All-Russian Congress of Peasant Deputies in May 1917, where he was selected as a member of the executive committee as part of the “left wing,” which was aligned closely with the Bolsheviks. He participated in the October Revolution, and was one of the first of the revolutionary troops to penetrate the Winter Palace in St. Petersburg.[iii] Although Drugov never mentions the name Dzevaltovskiy in his writings, the two eventual defectors likely crossed paths at this time, as both participated in the storming of the Winter Palace. The famous SR leader Maria Aleksandrovna Spiridonova recommended Drugov for membership in the Second Conference of Soviets, where he was elected as a member of the All-Union Central Executive Committee, also similar to Dzevaltovskiy. He later wrote that the Bolsheviks were willing to bring him, an anarchist, into the ruling circles because he could act as an intermediary between the two extreme leftist parties, the SRs and the Bolsheviks. Lenin personally agreed to give him a post on the Petrograd Revolutionary Military Council.[iv]

In about December 1917, Feliks Dzerzhinskiy invited him onto the ChK Collegium. Drugov’s tenure on the ChK Collegium lasted less than a year, but his assignments during that time paralleled the initial development of the ChK. The ChK was challenged from its beginnings by a large volume of detainees, many of which were simply caught up in Bolshevik sweeps through the countryside. Drugov was given several assignments to deal with detainee populations. In January1918, Dzerzhinskiy assigned Drugov to conduct searches of detainees held in the Kresty Prison in St. Petersburg, which at the time held several hundred detainees accused of “sabotage against the Soviet power.” Drugov had himself been detained as a terrorist at the Kresty Prison 10 years earlier. He entered the prison this time as a ChK officer, tasked with confiscating any weapons that the detainees possessed inside the prison, and executing summarily anyone found to have a weapon.[v]

By March 1918, St. Petersburg was increasingly threatened by advancing German troops and by anti-Bolshevik unrest, and the situation had grown serious enough that the Bolsheviks were grudgingly forced to evacuate the city they viewed as the cradle of the revolution. Drugov was given “dictatorial powers” to organize the evacuation of the ChK from St. Petersburg to Moscow, including moving hundreds of detainees.[vi] By the summer of 1918, the White Army was also threatening Moscow and the Soviet government began preparations to evacuate again. By this time, the number of detainees had grown to over 12,000, and Dzerzhinskiy assigned Drugov to be part of a committee to figure out what to do with the detainees if an evacuation became necessary. Dzerzhinskiy gave the committee only a few days to make a plan, and impatiently waited for the committee’s decision on how to identify which detainees should be executed to reduce the population.[vii]

Drugov also laid the foundation of the ChK’s clandestine activities. On 21 February 1918, Drugov, along with fellow Collegium members Vasiliy Vasilyevich Fomin and Ivan Nikolayevich Polukarov, was assigned to flesh out the ChK Charter and present it at the next committee meeting.[viii] Just a few days later, on 24 February, Drugov was assigned to organize ChK intelligence activities and report back to the committee.[ix] But despite his direct role in these foundational events, Drugov expressed unease with the methods that the ChK was adopting to deal with counterrevolutionaries and other undesirables. Describing discussions among the ChK Collegium members, he wrote:

Each of us felt in the depth of our souls that that we were called upon to create something similar to the old Okhrana[x] – and we were ashamed of the thought. It was completely obvious that the very character of the task before us would make it necessary to employ a system of surveillance and denunciations (of the latter, by the way, we had already accumulated quite a few). Who will fill the role of “stoolies”? On one hand, the thought sickened the revolutionaries, but on the other, such a task could only be assigned to people who were devoted to the revolution. How could that be?[xi]

On 13 April 1918, Drugov submitted a written resignation from the ChK Collegium because of a fundamental divergence between his views and the Committee’s actions in relation to his fellow anarchists.[xii] Although anarchists and SRs had aligned with Bolsheviks during the October Revolution, after a few months, as the SRs were exerting greater autonomy and diverging in their policies, the Bolsheviks began to exclude them from governing positions and round them up as criminals.[xiii] Drugov later told Finnish interrogators that he wrote a formal protest to Dzerzhinskiy when he learned that the ChK planned to disarm anarchists.[xiv] Drugov’s resignation came the day after a ChK operation to “cleanse” Moscow of anarchists, whom Dzerzhinskiy blamed for criminal activities, including narcotics trafficking.[xv] Likely with allies such as Drugov in mind, Dzerzhinskiy drew a distinction between criminal anarchists and “ideological” anarchists,[xvi] but the operation was apparently too much for Drugov to tolerate. While the Collegium deemed Drugov’s motivations for resigning to be groundless, it left the decision to him. He left, although apparently on friendly terms, because he was allowed to continue to use the ChK cafeteria.[xvii]

Drugov continued to work for the Soviet government for several more years, occupying various internal security positions, including as the deputy chief of clandestine operations for the Republic Special Purpose Unit (Часть Особого Назначения, ChON), which organized rank-and-file party members into revolutionary militias. He left because of illness in 1923. He was arrested in July 1925 for associating with an illegal Menshevik group, but was acquitted a year later by the OGPU Collegium, possibly with the help of ChK officials with whom he had worked in 1918.

He worked in odd jobs until 18 March 1930, when he took a boat from Sestroretsk, near Leningrad, to the city of Terijoki (now Zelenogorsk) just across what was then the Finnish border and surrendered himself to Finnish authorities.[xviii] He initially introduced himself using the name Leonard Frantsevich Benar and formally requested political asylum.[xix] He wrote a manifesto in that name, in which exulted in his freedom from the “nightmarish prison the world calls the ‘USSR’,” but also called attention to the millions of “enslaved, hungry, tortured” people in the Soviet Union who had no reason to celebrate. He appealed to the West to stop cooperating with the Soviet Union and stop purchasing Soviet goods, which legitimized a regime through which “on one fifth of the world’s surface for 13 years a bunch of criminals torments the body and soul of dozens of nations and 150,000,000 people.”[xx] He asked that his statement be published in a newspaper.

The Finns initially met his statements with skepticism. By mid-April he was transferred to Helsinki, and he addressed a note to the Finnish Political Police, in which he compared the initial mistrust that the Finns had shown him with his treatment in a Tsarist political prison in 1912. He included in his note a poem that he claimed to have written during his exile in Siberia:

My spirit did not fall in the difficult struggle,
Deciding to suffer for my ideas,
The horrors of life so familiar to me
For years I languished in prison,
Bound in chains, sentenced to death,
In Siberia I was exiled for my ideas.[xxi]

Eventually, he provided an extensive biographical statement explaining his anarchist-socialist activism, his work with the ChK, and his disagreement with Bolshevik methods. He also gave detailed information about the workings of the ChK, much of which he subsequently published in his “Confession of a Repentant Chekist” in February 1931.[xxii]

He was released from Finnish prison and relocated to Paris in mid-1930, from where in August he wrote a note to the Finnish government appealing for support in forming a clandestine organization to help anti-Bolshevik groups inside Russia. He asked for permission to establish a cell on the Soviet–Finnish border, either with active Finnish support, or at least tacit noninterference, that would act as a distribution point for sending anti-Bolshevik literature into the Soviet Union.[xxiii]

Drugov drafted a “Concept proposal for an international organization called the Liberty and Culture League,” in which he described an organization that would remove Bolshevism from Russia and replace it with a democratic socialist regime.[xxiv] Drugov’s Finnish State Police file contains no answer to his proposal, and the Finns may have been wary of such an offer, since they had fallen victim three years earlier to a purported anti-Bolshevik organization, the Trust, which turned out to be an OGPU deception operation. The Finnish government did consider, but dismissed the possibility that Drugov was an OGPU provocation when it decided whether to issue him a temporary residency permit.[xxv]

Drugov joined forces with Besedovskiy in Paris, writing for Besedovskiy’s magazine Борьба (Struggle). Not long after his arrival in Paris, Drugov published his “Confession,” which portrayed Dzerzhinskiy as a workaholic who was quick to order executions for any activity that he judged to be incompatible with the revolution. Drugov revealed his distaste for the methods that ChK was employing, with Dzerzhinskiy’s approval, in its struggle against counterrevolutionaries, comparing them with the methods of the Tsarist-era Okhana:

Some of the collegium members resented their job on moral grounds and spoke openly about it. Others, however, asserted that there was no need to worry about comparing ourselves with the pre-revolutionary Okhrana: it had protected the ruling class from the revolution, but we were called to protect the revolution from its enemies. That is an honorable task, and there was no need to be ashamed of it. Dzerzhinskiy was extremely pleased with that thought. He seized upon it immediately, developed it in a long and fervent speech and added that, ‘the ideological foundation of the VChK activities should be its motto – the goal justified the means.’[xxvi]

In February 1932, Drugov wrote a letter from Paris to a Mr. K. E. Stendahl of the Finnish Political Police in which he requested that the notes that he had made during his interrogations in Helsinki be sent to him in Paris, because he planned to write a book and he hoped to rely on those notes. He received the notes in March, but there is no indication that he ever wrote a book.

It is possible that he requested his notes from the Finnish government based on Soviet embassy instructions, because in 1932 Drugov offered his services again to the Soviet embassy in Paris. His activities in support of the embassy at this time are not documented, and his reason for rethinking his defection is not known. He may have found that émigrés grew tired of his “exposures” and, like other defectors of the time, he ran out of money. His socialist democratic “concept proposal” may have met resistance from monarchist Russian émigrés in Paris. Or, he may have been the targeted by the OGPU for recruitment. Although his reason is unknown, he agreed to return to the Soviet Union in July 1933 and was promptly arrested for illegally crossing the border and communicating sensitive information to a foreign government. His was executed on 23 February 1934. He was rehabilitated in 1993.[xxvii]

Notes

  1. [i] Vladimir Leonidovich Genis, “Фёдор Павлович Другов” (“Fedor Pavlovich Drugov”), Вопросы истории (Questions of History), No. 3 (March 2010), pp. 55-75.
  2. [ii] Photo from National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  3. [iii] Fedor Pavlovich Drugov, “Анархисты в русской революции: Октябрьские дни в Смольном” (“Anarchists in the Russian Revolution: The October Days in Smolniy”), Пробуждение (Awakening), 1932, Nos. 23-27. This series of articles describes the events that led to the storming of the Winter Palace.
  4. [iv] Drugov, “Anarchists in the Russian Revolution.”
  5. [v] Fedor Pavlovich Drugov, “С Дзержинским в ВЧК: Исповедь раскаявшегося чекиста” (“With Dzerzhinskiy in the VChK: The Confession of a Repentant Chekist”) Иллюстрированная Россия (Illustrated Russia), 7 February 1931, pp. 8-9. See also V. K. Vinogradov, Aleksey L. Litvin, Vasiliy S. Khristoforov, managing eds., Архив ВЧК. Сборник документов (The VChK Archive: A Collection of Documents) (Moscow: Kuchkovo Pole, 2007), p. 156, which provides a transcript of the minutes from the 14 January 1918 VChK Collegium meeting where Drugov received this assignment.
  6. [vi] Vinogradov, et al, The VChK Archive, minutes from VChK Collegium meetings on 5 March (p. 172), 7 March (p. 173) and 20 March 1918 (p. 185).
  7. [vii] Drugov, “Confession,” 21 February 1931, pp. 8-9.
  8. [viii] Vinogradov, et al, VChK Archive, p. 167.
  9. [ix] Vinogradov, et al, VChK Archive, p. 168.
  10. [x] The Tsarist-era secret service.
  11. [xi] Drugov, “Confession,” 31 January 1931, pp. 1.
  12. [xii] Vinogradov, et al, VChK Archive, p. 211
  13. [xiii] Lutz Häfner, “The Assassination of Count Mirbach and the July Uprising of the Left Socialist Revolutionaries in Moscow, 1918,” Russia Review, Vol. 50, Issue 3 (July 1991), p. 324-344.
  14. [xiv] Feodor Drugoff, “Моя Биография” (“My Biography”), handwritten statement given to Finnish police, National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  15. [xv] “Беседа с сотрудником газеты «Известия» о разоружении анархистов в Москве” (“Conversation with an Izvestiya Colleague about the Destruction of Anarchists in Moscow”), Izvestiya VTsIK, 16 April 1918. (available in the Aleksandr N. Yakovlev Archive, http://www.alexanderyakovlev.org/fond/issues-doc/1018183.)
  16. [xvi] Feodor Drugoff, “My Biography,” National Archives of Finland.
  17. [xvii] Vinogradov, et al, VChK Archive, p. 211.
  18. [xviii] Vinogradov, et al, VChK Archive, p. 673.
  19. [xix] Letter from L. Benar to the President of the Finnish Republic, dated 22 March 1930, National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  20. [xx] L. Benar, “Нации в Плену” (“Nations in Prison”), dated 20 March 1930, National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  21. [xxi] Note to Finnish Political Police, dated 17 April 1930, National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  22. [xxii] “Tietoja Venäjä vallankumouksen osanottajista” (“On the Participants of the Russian Revolution”), dated 5 April 1930, Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033. This report contains many of the same accounts that were published in Drugov’s “Confession.”
  23. [xxiii] Letter from Drugov in Paris, dated 29 August 1930, National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  24. [xxiv] “Vapauden ja Kulttuurin Liiga-nimisen Kansainvälisen järjeston ehdotelmakonsepti” (“Concept proposal for an international organization called the Liberty and Culture League”), National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  25. [xxv] Finnish Ministry of Foreign Affairs memo, dated 30 April 1930, National Archives of Finland, State Police (Valpo I) files, Box 102, folder 11033.
  26. [xxvi] Drugov, “Confession,” 31 January 1931, pp. 2.
  27. [xxvii] Vinogradov, et al, VChK Archive, p. 673; “Другов Федор Павлович (1891)” (“Fedor Pavlovich Drugov (1891)”), “Memorial” International, https://ru.openlist.wiki/Другов_Федор_Павлович_(1891).

Published works

  • "С Дзержинским в БЧК: Исповедь Раскаявшегося Чекиста" ("The Confession of a Repentant Chekist")
  • Иллюстрированная Россия (Illustrated Russia)
  • 7 February 1931. “Анархисты в русской революции: Октябрьские дни в Смольном” (“Anarchists in the Russian Revolution: The October Days in Smolniy”)
  • Пробуждение (Awakening)
  • 1932
  • Nos. 23-27.

Cite this entry

Kevin Riehle, “Drugov, Fedor Pavlovich,” Soviet Defectors Database, revised 2026-11-22, https://sovietdefectors.com/defector/drugov-fedor-pavlovich/