Intelligence and state security officers who left Soviet serviceCompiled by Kevin Riehle

Entry 10 of 121 · revised 2026-11-22

Yevgeniy Vasiliyevich Dumbadze

Евгений Васильевич Думбадзе

Biography

Most of what we know about Yevgeniy Vasilyevich Dumbadze comes from his own writings with few corroborating sources. His most famous published work was his book, На Службе Чека и Коинтерна: Личные воспоминания (In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern: Personal Reminiscences), published in Paris in 1930, which is primarily a rationalization for how, after beginning as an enthusiastic believer, he came to oppose the Bolshevik Party and eventually make his break from Soviet control. His book was originally published serially, possibly with the help of prominent anti-Bolshevik activist Vladimir Lvovich Burtsev, who wrote a foreword to the 1930 book.[i] While the book provides glimpses into the Soviet intelligence and security activities of the 1920s, it also contains some dubious elements, which created doubt among some Russian émigrés in Europe about his sincerity as a defector.[ii]

According to his passport, Dumbadze was born in June 1900 in Krasnovodsk on the eastern shore of the Caspian Sea, and he greeted the events of 1917 as an idealistic teenager. He joined the Red Army in 1918 and soon became the commissar of a regiment. He fulfilled his duties with vigor, and by 1920 was assigned as a division commissar. Similar to Ignatiy Dzevaltovskiy (see separatge entry in this database), Dumbadze found himself, as a 20-year-old, being ordered to contradict an experienced colonel on a question of military tactics. The colonel brought charges against him for contradicting an order; however, because Dumbadze was a political officer fulfilling his Party responsibilities, he was acquitted of any wrongdoing, even though his actions made little tactical military sense.[iii]

He continued in the Red Army until June 1921, when he was demobilized and assigned to the newly formed Tbilisi Committee of the Bolshevik Party, where he helped organize Bolshevik activities in Georgia. He requested to be sent to university to complete his education; however, the Party had other plans for him, assigning him instead to the Georgian ChK, which he accepted as a great honor.[iv] He described the members of the ChK in 1921 as consisting of “green, revolutionary youth,” naive and enthusiastic about the Bolshevik cause, and ready to do whatever the Party ordered. He was assigned to a surveillance unit responsible for recruiting agents to monitor the loyalty of the local population.[v]

About half of his book is dedicated to anecdotes about his ChK service, first in Tbilisi and then in Poti, Georgia. He describes the arrests, detentions, and executions of hundreds of Georgians, many of whom were accused of anti-Bolshevik agitation, primarily as Mensheviks or nationalists. He draws a detailed picture of ChK “cellars,” where interrogators used a variety of psychological and physical means to elicit information from detainees. Echoing descriptions given by Petr Karpov and Aleksandr Sipelgas (see separate entries in this database), Dumbadze reported that a detainee could leave a “cellar” usually for only one of two reasons: he had either been coerced into becoming a ChK informant or he was en route to execution.

It was during this time, while participating in ChK interrogations and summary executions, when Dumbadze claimed the first cracks in his idealistic view of Bolshevism began to form. He describes feelings of guilt and repulsion when he witnessed the interrogation of an old woman who refused to reveal the whereabouts of her own son; she was subsequently executed.[vi] He was assigned as a duty officer to witness several execution sessions, where a ChK executioner killed over a dozen people whose dead bodies fell into shallow common graves after they were shot. He wrote, ”These scenes in particular had a decisive influence on my decision to break with the Bolsheviks.”[vii]

In both Tbilisi and Poti he describes the extreme behavior of some OGPU officers and Party officials, who created further doubts in his mind about the justness of the Bolshevik system. One individual, whom he names Shulman, was an executioner who used cocaine to dull his senses while fulfilling his deadly assignments.[viii] He described an individual named Lobadze, a Georgian bandit whom the ChK used for dirty jobs until he was eventually murdered himself when he was no longer useful.[ix] He recounted an occasion when a Railway ChK officer approached Grigol Ordzhonikidze, a senior Communist Party official who was traveling through Georgia by train, and asked for his ticket. Ordzhonikidze reportedly demanded that the officer be arrested for bothering a senior Party official.[x] Dumbadze also wrote of a ChK supervisor named Denyaga, who was accused of rape, but protected by a friend on the Politburo in Tbilisi. He was eventually arrested but served only a short time in prison and was subsequently assigned as a police commander.[xi] The contrast between the ideals of Bolshevism and the reality reflected in these officials had a strong impact on Dumbadze’s commitment to the cause.

While most of the operations that Dumbadze experienced in the early 1920s were related to domestic security, he also described several foreign-related operations. He told of a train robbery that the GPU staged in order to steal documents from an American journalist traveling through the Caucasus.[xii] He also claimed that the GPU was involved in the 1922 assassination of Turkish diplomat Jemal Pasha, who was transiting Georgia on a return trip from Afghanistan to Turkey. The assassination was organized by a group of Armenian nationalists affiliated with the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun), whom the GPU arrested soon after the event; however, the assassins were given light sentences and soon released. Dumbadze says he later learned that Jemal Pasha was murdered on the order of the GPU.[xiii]

Dumbadze was demobilized from the ChK in 1923 and returned to party work, receiving an assignment to the Central Union of Georgia, where he says his disenchantment with Bolshevism grew even stronger. While in Tbilisi, his “deviant” behavior in relation to the party began to manifest itself openly, and he was among a group of party members who voted against a party position on Georgian nationalism. He was forced to leave Georgia, was exiled for a short time to Murmansk, but eventually made his way to Leningrad, where he began to associate with illegal, anti-Stalinist oppositionist groups.[xiv]

His story loses credibility when he states that, despite his openly oppositionist activities, he finally got his chance to attend university. With the help of a recommendation from the Ajarian Central Executive Committee, he enrolled in the Leningrad Institute of Oriental Languages, from which he graduated in 1928. His oppositionist activities did not prevent him from receiving a foreign assignment in the Soviet trade representation in Istanbul, Turkey.

He arrived in Istanbul in early 1928 and began working as a Comintern agent in the trade representation, where he was approached by the OGPU rezident and recruited as an informant to monitor the Russian émigré population. However, rather than enthusiastically fulfilling his tasks as he would have done a few years earlier, he decided to use his foreign assignment as an opportunity to escape Soviet control. His escape from Istanbul is another episode that strains credibility; taking a great risk, he informed the OGPU rezident of his plans to travel to Paris for the purpose of ingratiating himself more fully into the émigré community for OGPU purposes. However, when he arrived in Paris in July 1928, he made contact with anti-Bolshevik émigrés, joining them rather than working against them. Another anomaly in his story is that he traveled from Istanbul to Paris on a true-name passport, assuming that Dumbadze is his real name.[xv]

He probably initially turned himself over to French intelligence. Russian State Military Archives indicate that Vladimir Orlov—the same person who was tried in Germany alongside Karpov in 1929—directly supported French counterintelligence interrogations of Dumbadze when he first arrived in France in 1928.[xvi] Another account claimed that Dumbadze later assisted the French intelligence service to steal thousands of documents from Vladimir Orlov’s archives in Brussels.[xvii]

Dumbadze soon became a vocal anti-Soviet activist in Paris, and later in Brussels. Dumbadze’s arrival in France split the Paris-based anti-Bolshevik émigré community, some believing he was a genuine defector and others suspecting him of being a Soviet provocation. Georgiy Aleksandrovich Solomon, a Soviet non-returnee from the Russian trade representation in London in 1923, wrote a foreword to Dumbadze’s book, affirming that “These memoirs represent something terrible, for they are written by a person who personally lived through all of the depicted events, and being unable to withstand those horrors, and despite great difficulty and danger, forsook that accursed service.”[xviii] Vladimir Burtsev, who also had strong anti-Bolshevik credentials, provided a second foreword to Dumbadze’s book: “The author, based on his personal reminiscences, describes the characteristics of Soviet life against which he himself wants to fight, and against which he calls on others to fight. No one except people who had previously been in Y. V. Dumbadze’s position could with such force and such knowledge portray to readers the essence of what he calls others to fight against.”[xix]

However, other émigrés were not as convinced. In March 1930, the émigré newspaper Vozrozhdenie reported that Dumbadze traveled to Brussels in January 1930, but had disappeared from Brussels and was suspected of having traveled to Moscow. The report added that his father was believed to still be working as a policeman in Baku, Azerbaijan, which raised additional suspicion about the sincerity of his break from the Soviet Union.[xx] The following week, however, the newspaper was forced to correct its report after an “indecent” letter from Dumbadze showed that he was still in Belgium, not in Moscow.[xxi] The following month Vozrozhdenie wrote disdainfully that Dumbadze was leading a group of ex-Communist émigrés that viewed itself as the only legitimate revolutionary opposition to the Soviet Union, and that only those who had come from inside the Soviet Union could successfully resist Soviet power.[xxii] The editors found it difficult to believe that someone who had admittedly been involved in ChK executions could now be a genuine anti-Bolshevik.[xxiii]

Dumbadze mentioned two other purported intelligence officer defectors in his book who are not identified anywhere else. As Dumbadze often uses pseudonyms for people in his book, it is unclear whether these individuals’ names are genuine. For one Dumbadze gives only the name Erman, identifying him as the chief of a border guard unit in Batumi, Georgia, in 1923. Each month, Erman rounded up cobblers and tailors, accusing them of manufacturing their goods using contraband materials, and extracting “fines” from them. Erman claimed that they received the illegal materials from Ajarians, and that the contraband activities would only end when all Ajarians were executed. Erman was later promoted and transferred to Leningrad, but the OGPU conducted an investigation into his operations in Georgia, determining that he, along with rest of the border control office in Batumi, had been defrauding the local population. Erman was arrested in Leningrad, but later escaped abroad.[xxiv]

The second was an individual named Galitskiy, a Razvedupr officer assigned to the Soviet consulate in Istanbul. Galitskiy was recruited by the Turkish police and provided the identities of his agents and other classified information. Galitskiy defected to the Turks in 1928 and lived for a time on the money he made by selling secrets. But eventually he ran out of money and the Turks hired him into service with the Turkish police. His new employers recommended him for a clandestine assignment back inside Russia, but he initially refused, claiming that such a mission would be a death sentence. However, the Turks insisted and he traveled to Russia, where he was arrested and executed.[xxv]

Whether these two defectors are real people or metaphors for Dumbadze’s views of the OGPU is unclear. However, his story about Galitskiy contains some parallels with another monograph Dumbadze wrote in September 1933. Beginning in 1930, Dumbadze assisted another OGPU defector, Georgiy Sergeyevich Arutyunov (Agabekov (see separate entry in this database), who followed a similar path from Istanbul to Paris and Brussels. Dumbadze jealously claims that Arutyunov had enjoyed fame and fortune for several years because of his revelations about Soviet intelligence activities that he both published and provided secretly to European intelligence services. However, according to Dumbadze, by 1933 Arutyunov began to run out of information to sell, and he turned to a deception operation to defraud the Romanian intelligence service of money. Arutyunov brought Dumbadze into his confidence in support of the operation, but through double-dealing Dumbadze spoiled it, claiming that it would have harmed the reputation of other Russian émigrés. He wrote a monograph about Arutyunov in 1933, but there is no indication that it was ever published.[xxvi] By this time, his relationship with Arutyunov was irreparably damaged.

Little is known of Dumbadze’s whereabouts from 1933 until 1939, when Vladimir Orlov, whose archives Dumbadze had allegedly stolen, wrote a letter to Vladimir Burtsev, dated 4 March 1939. Orlov writes that he had no recent news of Dumbadze, but that Orlov had informed anyone who would listen about Dumbadze’s fraudulent activities, particularly, according to Orlov, about Dumbadze stealing his archives and selling them to Moscow.[xxvii] Orlov clearly held a grudge against Dumbadze, and it is unclear whether the allegation of dealings with Moscow was factual or a poison pen. Nevertheless, Dumbadze’s reputation among Russian émigrés, possibly even with Burtsev, who had written a favorable foreword to Dumbadze’s book eight years earlier, was severely tarnished.

Notes

  1. [i] “Исчезновение Думбадзе” (“Dumbadze’s Disappearance”), Vozrozhdenie, 1 March 1930, p. 1.
  2. [ii] Yevgeniy Vasilyevich Dumbadze, На Службе Чека и Коинтерна: Личные воспоминания (In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern: Personal Reminiscences) (Paris: Mishen, 1930). A draft typescript of the book is in Hoover Institution Archives, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 294, Folder 18 (microfilm reel 254). Dumbadze’s book was also translated into French under the title L’Homme qui Assassinait: Confession d’un Tchekiste (The Man who Murdered: Confession of a Chekist), a typescript for which is in the Hoover Institution Archives, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 294, Folder 20 (microfilm reel 254).
  3. [iii] Dumbadze, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, pp. 27-28.
  4. [iv] Ibid, p. 30-33.
  5. [v] Ibid, p. 34.
  6. [vi] Ibid, pp. 50-52.
  7. [vii] Ibid, p. 59.
  8. [viii] Ibid, pp. 60-64. See also (Igor Simbirtsev, ВЧК в ленинской России. 1917–1922: В зареве революции (VChK in Lenin’s Russia, 1917-1922: In the Glow of the Revolution) (Moscow: Tsentropoligraf, 2008), which describes probably the same Shulman, who eventually went insane.
  9. [ix] Dumbadze, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, pp. 73-73.
  10. [x] Ibid, pp. 93-96.
  11. [xi] Ibid, p. 105
  12. [xii] Ibid, pp. 70-72
  13. [xiii] Ibid, pp. 72-73. Other sources attribute the assassination to Operation Nemesis, an Armenian nationalist assassination campaign directed against the organizers of the Armenian genocide; see Jacques Derogy, Resistance and Revenge: The Armenian Assassination of the Turkish Leaders Responsible for the 1915 Massacres and Deportations (Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 1990), p. xxvii.
  14. [xiv] Dumbadze, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, pp. 121-125.
  15. [xv] Photographs of his passport are published in his book, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, pp. 135, 137. Unlike other defectors, there is no indication that Dumbadze used multiple pseudonyms. The only other name Dumbadze mentions for himself is the handle Rokua, which he used as a ChK/GPU officer in Georgia; see Dumbadze, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, p. 43.
  16. [xvi] Nikolay Stepanovich Batyushin, У истоков русской контрразведки. Сборник документов и материалов (At the Root of Russian Counterintelligence: A Collection of Documents and Materials) (Berlin: Directmedia, 2013) p. 264.
  17. [xvii] Lev Mnukhin, Maria Avril, Veronika Losskaya, Российское зарубежье во Франции 1919-2000: Биографический словарь (Russia Abroad in France: A Biographical Dictionary) (Moscow: Nauka, 2008), pp. 515-516.
  18. [xviii] Dumbadze, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, p. 7.
  19. [xix] Ibid., p. 11.
  20. [xx] “Исчезновение Думбадзе” (“Dumbadze’s Disappearance”), Vozrozhdenie, 1 March 1930, p. 1.
  21. [xxi] “Думбадзе в Бельги” (“Dumbadze in Belgium”), Vozrozhdenie, 8 March 1930, p. 1.
  22. [xxii] “Каждый День” (“Every Day”), Vozrozhdenie, 19 April 1930, p. 2.
  23. [xxiii] “Бурцевслий Протокол (“Burtsev’s Agreement”), Vozrozhdenie, 21 October 1930, p. 1.
  24. [xxiv] Dumbadze, In the Service of the Cheka and the Komintern, pp. 107-108.
  25. [xxv] Ibid, p. 153.
  26. [xxvi] Yevgeniy Vasilyevich Dumbadze, Дело Агабекова-Арутюнова (The Agabekov-Arutyunov Affair), typescript in Hoover Institution Archives, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 294, Folders 21 and 22 (microfilm reel 254).
  27. [xxvii] Letter from Vladimir Orlov to Vladimir Burtsev, dated 4 March 1939 in Brussels, Hoover Institution Archives, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 151, Folder 35 (microfilm reel 128).

Published works

  • На службе Чека и Коминтерна. Личные воспоминания (In the Service of the Cheka and Comintern: Personal Recollections) (Paris: Mishen
  • 1930).

Cite this entry

Kevin Riehle, “Dumbadze, Yevgeniy Vasiliyevich,” Soviet Defectors Database, revised 2026-11-22, https://sovietdefectors.com/defector/dumbadze-yevgeniy-vasiliyevich/