Biography
Better known as Mikhail Vasilyevich Shatov,[i] the name he assumed in a refugee camp after World War II to avoid forced repatriation, Petr Vasilyevich Kashtanov served a brief career as an NKVD political officer prior to his capture in 1942.
His birth date is a matter of debate, probably because of the false identity he assumed in the refugee camp. He claimed the birthdate 5 July 1920 in his Shatov persona.[ii] However, during an interview for the Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System, he stated that he was 19 years old in 1936, placing his birth year in 1917.[iii] The earlier birthdate is more plausible, because he states that he became a member of the Komsomol in 1932, which was more likely at 15 years old than 12.[iv]
Kashtanov’s father was a senior Party member, having been in the Party since 1920. He worked in the Workers’ and Peasants Inspectorate (Рабоче-Крестьянская Инспекция; RKI), a body that exercised control over Party organs to ensure their effectiveness, and later served as a judge in Soviet courts. Kashtanov notes that despite his father’s Party status, his mother was a religious believer and tried to instill religious views in Kashtanov.[v]
Kashtanov talked little about his childhood, but told of one experience that occurred when he was a teenager living in Moscow that left in him with a lasting a fear of police. He recounts that he was walking to school past the Kremlin when he saw a motorcade carrying Stalin and members of the Politburo. He was excited about getting such a close up view of these eminent figures, and he wrote a note to a friend about the experience. On the way home from school the same day he saw the motorcade again and stopped to watch, but NKVD security personnel arrested him and he was forced to explain himself. He got out of the situation with the help of relatives in the government. He later said that his fear of police continued even after the war when he saw an American jeep in Austria for the first time and ran away from it.[vi]
The incident had no long-term ramifications for Kashtanov’s career, and in 1936 he worked for five months as an administrator in a planning section in a district of the Moscow Oblast. He was responsible for collecting the plans, manpower, and livestock figures, and raw material requirements of enterprises in the district, such as sovkhozes, kolkhozes, and factories, and compiling them into a district plan. After this job, he went to work as a foreman in a factory that manufactured artillery shells. He moved after a short while to be a planner in the factory in the office that ordered supplies and raw material for factory production.[vii]
While he was working these various jobs, he also attended a naval non-commissioned officers school part time, where students prepared for Navy service abroad. He had joined the Komsomol in 1932, and he also served as the Komsomol secretary for the naval school, which gave him visibility with the Party leadership. This led to him becoming a candidate for Party membership in 1938 and a full member in 1939.
In 1939, his Party leaders selected him to attend the Military-Political School of the NKVD Forces in Sevastopol, where he took officer training courses, political courses, and courses in the Border Guard service. He claimed during a Harvard Project interview that he read the memoirs of old Bolsheviks during this time and he began to see the contrast between the Soviet purges and the pre-revolutionary methods, especially the comparatively easy conditions under which communist exiles lived during tsarist times. But he could not express his concerns to his colleagues and kept them to himself.[viii]
He graduated from the NKVD school in 1941 and was assigned as a political officer in a NKVD forces company, where he provided political indoctrination for company soldiers and continued his Party work as secretary of the division party commission.[ix]
Zhukov and Kovtun provide a different chronology of events, writing that Kashtanov transferred from the school in Sevastopol to the Leningrad Military-Political Academy of the NKVD forces. But the German attack on the Soviet Union interrupted his education, and he was deployed as a sergeant in the NKVD border guard forces.[x]
Either way, his time in the NKVD lasted less than a year. Konstantin Grigoryevich Kromiadi, a long-time Russian émigré who became Kashtanov’s close friend, wrote that Kashtanov was captured after his Soviet Army unit was defeated in battle in February 1942. Kashtanov hid in the forest for two weeks with freezing hands and feet, and he later told Kromiadi that he joined the RNNA simply get food and a warm place to stay, planning to escape back into the forest to join the partisans. He stayed instead and saw action in RNNA operations against partisans, where he was injured in the stomach by a grenade later in 1942. He recovered and eventually became an associate of Vlasov, even leading his personal security detail.[xi]
He remained with the ROA until the war ended, and he escaped repatriation and settled in the French occupation sector of Germany, near the town of Ravensburg. Kromiadi described a close call for Kashtanov in the summer of 1946, when officers from the Soviet Repatriation Commission came to Kashtanov’s house. The officers broke the lock and ransacked the house, but Kashtanov fled out the back. The French occupation authorities refused to take action on the break-in.[xii] Kashtanov later complained much about the treatment of Soviet refugees in Germany, especially perceiving that former ROA members were being singled out for unfair treatment.[xiii]
His experiences in both the RNNA and the ROA set the theme of much of his work after the war. In 1948 he wrote a monograph titled От Р.Н.Н.А. к Р.О.А. (From the RNNA to the ROA), in which he described the activities of the RNNA and the eventual transition of many RNNA officers to the ROA. His first encounter with the RNNA was when he was in a POW camp near Orsha, Belarus, and RNNA officers recruited among the Soviet POWs.[xiv] He notes that the RNNA conflicted with its German commanders on the question of fighting partisans, with the Germans wanting the unit to be more aggressive. He noted that, after a major re-defection of RNNA units to the Soviet side in January 1943, the RNNA effectively ceased to exist. Years later, after he had emigrated to the United States, he also published a Bibliography on the Vlassov Movement in World War II, 1941-1945, in which he collected published works in Russian, German, and English that were held at Columbia University that covered the formation, personnel, and dissolution of the ROA.[xv]
Beginning in 1949, Kashtanov maintained a correspondence with Boris Nikolaevsky in New York, lasting until Nikolaevsky’s death in 1966. In August 1949, Nikolaevsky requested that Kashtanov write about the NKVD, claiming “we know nothing about it, and we need to know.”[xvi] By “we,” Nikolavesky was referring to David Dallin and himself; the two had co-authored a book in 1947 titled Forced Labor in Soviet Russia relying in part on the accounts of Soviet refugees in refugee camps in Germany.[xvii] Their interest in the NKVD and its workings was probably an extension of the research they had done for their earlier book.
Kashtanov undertook such a work, and over the following three years, he and Kromiadi, using the pseudonyms Yuriy Koreyskiy and Ed. Prokratskiy respectively, collaborated to write a book entitled Паук и Сети (Spider and Webs). He sent Nikolaevsky an outline for the book in November 1949, and each month or two Kashtanov sent Nikolaevsky a new chapter.[xviii]
The chapter outline is as follows:
· Chapter 1: NKVD organization at the kray, oblast, and republic levels (a fictitious division of the ministry, done to satisfy world opinion, did not change the NKVD’s methods)
· Chapter 2: NKVD sections
· Chapter 3: NKVD personnel (ranks, positions, rank insignia, etc.)
· Chapter 4: Clandestine operational network (informants, special information, agents, traveling agents, internal agents, rezidents)
· Chapter 5: Methods of recruiting agents for clandestine informant networks (секретно-осведомительные сети; SOS) in factories, plants, departments, educational institutions, handicraft unions, kolkhozes, sovkhozes, restaurants, institutes, etc.)
· Chapter 6: Disposition of SOSes around targets
· Chapter 7: Methods of operation of operational staff (staff NKVD workers) with clandestine networks
· Chapter 8: Methods of operation of SOSes in targets
· Chapter 9: Surveillance and its methods
· Chapter 10: Foreign Department
· Chapter 11: Assessing the work and evaluating materials of SOSes; classification, and payment
· Chapter 12: Use of agent materials in the State Security apparatus
· Chapter 13: Assessment and analysis of anti-Soviet elements (counterrevolutionaries); Order 1138 of 1932.
· Chapter 14: Methods of conducting investigations
· Chapter 15: Shipbuilding
· Chapter 16: NKVD Schools
· Chapter 17: Collectivization of agriculture and liquidation of “kulaks” by the NKVD forces
· Chapter 18: The partisan movement and the role of the NKVD in its development
· Chapter 19: The Army and the NKVD
· Chapter 20: Protecting leaders, great and small
· Chapter 21: Border guard forces and ties with the NKVD
Kashtanov’s book was heavily concentrated on internal security, investigations, and administrative matters, with little information about foreign operations; although the outline contained a chapter on the NKVD Foreign Department, no such chapter appears in the manuscript. He appears to base portions of his book on his time working as an economic planner in the mid-1930s, as he describes the collection of local planning data and the opportunities for fraud, which the NKVD Economic Department investigated. His material probably also derives from his border guard training at the NKVD school in Sevastopol.[xix]
Kashtanov continued to work to the book from 1949 to 1952. The title changed after Kashtanov arrived in the Unites States in 1952 to НКВД и Его Нити (The NKVD and its Threads). However, the book was never published with either title, and the manuscript sat in Nikolaevsky’s and Dallin’s personal papers, and in the archives of the Research Program on the USSR at Columbia University. In March 1950, Nikolaevsky informed Kashtanov that the material was not in a form suitable for publication. Although the manuscript was very interesting, and both Nikolaevsky and Dallin were reading it, Nikolaevsky explained that the manuscript “was material for a book, but not a book.”[xx]
In 1950 or 1951, Kashtanov was interviewed for the Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System (dates of the interviews are not noted). Then in January 1952, after trying for several years to obtain permission, Kashtanov emigrated to the United States. From 1955 to 1971 he worked in the Columbia University Library, where he authored bibliographic works on Russian-language publications. He also became the leader of the anti-Soviet group Union for the Struggle for the Liberation of the Peoples of Russia (Союз Борьбы за Освобождение Народов России, SBONR).
In June 1956, Kashtanov testified before the U.S. Senate Internal Security Subcommittee about efforts by two Soviet individuals, Aleksey Petukhov and Rostislav Shapovalov, to pressure him to return to Russia. The two were studying English at Columbia University in the same class as Kashtanov, and Shapovalov was a diplomat at the Soviet Mission to the UN delegates, and Petukhov was employed in the United Nations secretariat in New York. Kashtanov stated that in April 1956, both had approached him asking why he had taken an anti-Soviet tone in his writings, claiming that the U.S. political position on the Soviet Union would fail and it would be better for Soviet emigres if they supported the Soviet side. The Soviet officers were aware of Kashtanov’s true identity and his affiliation with Vlasov’s Army during the war.[xxi] Kashtanov’s account of the Soviets’ pressuring him was later broadcast into the Soviet Union by Radio Liberation. The event came just a few weeks after the redefection of five Soviet merchant marines from the oil tanker Tuapse, who had jumped ship in Taiwan and were brought to the United States, but soon returned to the Soviet Union. Kashtanov’s story was a direct counter to Soviet propaganda stating that the Tuapse seamen had voluntarily returned. Shapovalov was expelled from the United States in September.[xxii]
He became a vocal anti-Soviet commentator, and in 1973, he was among the founding members of Congress of Russian Americans, which advocated for Russian refugee and immigration causes. Kashtanov died in October 1980 in New York.[xxiii]
His birth date is a matter of debate, probably because of the false identity he assumed in the refugee camp. He claimed the birthdate 5 July 1920 in his Shatov persona.[ii] However, during an interview for the Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System, he stated that he was 19 years old in 1936, placing his birth year in 1917.[iii] The earlier birthdate is more plausible, because he states that he became a member of the Komsomol in 1932, which was more likely at 15 years old than 12.[iv]
Kashtanov’s father was a senior Party member, having been in the Party since 1920. He worked in the Workers’ and Peasants Inspectorate (Рабоче-Крестьянская Инспекция; RKI), a body that exercised control over Party organs to ensure their effectiveness, and later served as a judge in Soviet courts. Kashtanov notes that despite his father’s Party status, his mother was a religious believer and tried to instill religious views in Kashtanov.[v]
Kashtanov talked little about his childhood, but told of one experience that occurred when he was a teenager living in Moscow that left in him with a lasting a fear of police. He recounts that he was walking to school past the Kremlin when he saw a motorcade carrying Stalin and members of the Politburo. He was excited about getting such a close up view of these eminent figures, and he wrote a note to a friend about the experience. On the way home from school the same day he saw the motorcade again and stopped to watch, but NKVD security personnel arrested him and he was forced to explain himself. He got out of the situation with the help of relatives in the government. He later said that his fear of police continued even after the war when he saw an American jeep in Austria for the first time and ran away from it.[vi]
The incident had no long-term ramifications for Kashtanov’s career, and in 1936 he worked for five months as an administrator in a planning section in a district of the Moscow Oblast. He was responsible for collecting the plans, manpower, and livestock figures, and raw material requirements of enterprises in the district, such as sovkhozes, kolkhozes, and factories, and compiling them into a district plan. After this job, he went to work as a foreman in a factory that manufactured artillery shells. He moved after a short while to be a planner in the factory in the office that ordered supplies and raw material for factory production.[vii]
While he was working these various jobs, he also attended a naval non-commissioned officers school part time, where students prepared for Navy service abroad. He had joined the Komsomol in 1932, and he also served as the Komsomol secretary for the naval school, which gave him visibility with the Party leadership. This led to him becoming a candidate for Party membership in 1938 and a full member in 1939.
In 1939, his Party leaders selected him to attend the Military-Political School of the NKVD Forces in Sevastopol, where he took officer training courses, political courses, and courses in the Border Guard service. He claimed during a Harvard Project interview that he read the memoirs of old Bolsheviks during this time and he began to see the contrast between the Soviet purges and the pre-revolutionary methods, especially the comparatively easy conditions under which communist exiles lived during tsarist times. But he could not express his concerns to his colleagues and kept them to himself.[viii]
He graduated from the NKVD school in 1941 and was assigned as a political officer in a NKVD forces company, where he provided political indoctrination for company soldiers and continued his Party work as secretary of the division party commission.[ix]
Zhukov and Kovtun provide a different chronology of events, writing that Kashtanov transferred from the school in Sevastopol to the Leningrad Military-Political Academy of the NKVD forces. But the German attack on the Soviet Union interrupted his education, and he was deployed as a sergeant in the NKVD border guard forces.[x]
Either way, his time in the NKVD lasted less than a year. Konstantin Grigoryevich Kromiadi, a long-time Russian émigré who became Kashtanov’s close friend, wrote that Kashtanov was captured after his Soviet Army unit was defeated in battle in February 1942. Kashtanov hid in the forest for two weeks with freezing hands and feet, and he later told Kromiadi that he joined the RNNA simply get food and a warm place to stay, planning to escape back into the forest to join the partisans. He stayed instead and saw action in RNNA operations against partisans, where he was injured in the stomach by a grenade later in 1942. He recovered and eventually became an associate of Vlasov, even leading his personal security detail.[xi]
He remained with the ROA until the war ended, and he escaped repatriation and settled in the French occupation sector of Germany, near the town of Ravensburg. Kromiadi described a close call for Kashtanov in the summer of 1946, when officers from the Soviet Repatriation Commission came to Kashtanov’s house. The officers broke the lock and ransacked the house, but Kashtanov fled out the back. The French occupation authorities refused to take action on the break-in.[xii] Kashtanov later complained much about the treatment of Soviet refugees in Germany, especially perceiving that former ROA members were being singled out for unfair treatment.[xiii]
His experiences in both the RNNA and the ROA set the theme of much of his work after the war. In 1948 he wrote a monograph titled От Р.Н.Н.А. к Р.О.А. (From the RNNA to the ROA), in which he described the activities of the RNNA and the eventual transition of many RNNA officers to the ROA. His first encounter with the RNNA was when he was in a POW camp near Orsha, Belarus, and RNNA officers recruited among the Soviet POWs.[xiv] He notes that the RNNA conflicted with its German commanders on the question of fighting partisans, with the Germans wanting the unit to be more aggressive. He noted that, after a major re-defection of RNNA units to the Soviet side in January 1943, the RNNA effectively ceased to exist. Years later, after he had emigrated to the United States, he also published a Bibliography on the Vlassov Movement in World War II, 1941-1945, in which he collected published works in Russian, German, and English that were held at Columbia University that covered the formation, personnel, and dissolution of the ROA.[xv]
Beginning in 1949, Kashtanov maintained a correspondence with Boris Nikolaevsky in New York, lasting until Nikolaevsky’s death in 1966. In August 1949, Nikolaevsky requested that Kashtanov write about the NKVD, claiming “we know nothing about it, and we need to know.”[xvi] By “we,” Nikolavesky was referring to David Dallin and himself; the two had co-authored a book in 1947 titled Forced Labor in Soviet Russia relying in part on the accounts of Soviet refugees in refugee camps in Germany.[xvii] Their interest in the NKVD and its workings was probably an extension of the research they had done for their earlier book.
Kashtanov undertook such a work, and over the following three years, he and Kromiadi, using the pseudonyms Yuriy Koreyskiy and Ed. Prokratskiy respectively, collaborated to write a book entitled Паук и Сети (Spider and Webs). He sent Nikolaevsky an outline for the book in November 1949, and each month or two Kashtanov sent Nikolaevsky a new chapter.[xviii]
The chapter outline is as follows:
· Chapter 1: NKVD organization at the kray, oblast, and republic levels (a fictitious division of the ministry, done to satisfy world opinion, did not change the NKVD’s methods)
· Chapter 2: NKVD sections
· Chapter 3: NKVD personnel (ranks, positions, rank insignia, etc.)
· Chapter 4: Clandestine operational network (informants, special information, agents, traveling agents, internal agents, rezidents)
· Chapter 5: Methods of recruiting agents for clandestine informant networks (секретно-осведомительные сети; SOS) in factories, plants, departments, educational institutions, handicraft unions, kolkhozes, sovkhozes, restaurants, institutes, etc.)
· Chapter 6: Disposition of SOSes around targets
· Chapter 7: Methods of operation of operational staff (staff NKVD workers) with clandestine networks
· Chapter 8: Methods of operation of SOSes in targets
· Chapter 9: Surveillance and its methods
· Chapter 10: Foreign Department
· Chapter 11: Assessing the work and evaluating materials of SOSes; classification, and payment
· Chapter 12: Use of agent materials in the State Security apparatus
· Chapter 13: Assessment and analysis of anti-Soviet elements (counterrevolutionaries); Order 1138 of 1932.
· Chapter 14: Methods of conducting investigations
· Chapter 15: Shipbuilding
· Chapter 16: NKVD Schools
· Chapter 17: Collectivization of agriculture and liquidation of “kulaks” by the NKVD forces
· Chapter 18: The partisan movement and the role of the NKVD in its development
· Chapter 19: The Army and the NKVD
· Chapter 20: Protecting leaders, great and small
· Chapter 21: Border guard forces and ties with the NKVD
Kashtanov’s book was heavily concentrated on internal security, investigations, and administrative matters, with little information about foreign operations; although the outline contained a chapter on the NKVD Foreign Department, no such chapter appears in the manuscript. He appears to base portions of his book on his time working as an economic planner in the mid-1930s, as he describes the collection of local planning data and the opportunities for fraud, which the NKVD Economic Department investigated. His material probably also derives from his border guard training at the NKVD school in Sevastopol.[xix]
Kashtanov continued to work to the book from 1949 to 1952. The title changed after Kashtanov arrived in the Unites States in 1952 to НКВД и Его Нити (The NKVD and its Threads). However, the book was never published with either title, and the manuscript sat in Nikolaevsky’s and Dallin’s personal papers, and in the archives of the Research Program on the USSR at Columbia University. In March 1950, Nikolaevsky informed Kashtanov that the material was not in a form suitable for publication. Although the manuscript was very interesting, and both Nikolaevsky and Dallin were reading it, Nikolaevsky explained that the manuscript “was material for a book, but not a book.”[xx]
In 1950 or 1951, Kashtanov was interviewed for the Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System (dates of the interviews are not noted). Then in January 1952, after trying for several years to obtain permission, Kashtanov emigrated to the United States. From 1955 to 1971 he worked in the Columbia University Library, where he authored bibliographic works on Russian-language publications. He also became the leader of the anti-Soviet group Union for the Struggle for the Liberation of the Peoples of Russia (Союз Борьбы за Освобождение Народов России, SBONR).
In June 1956, Kashtanov testified before the U.S. Senate Internal Security Subcommittee about efforts by two Soviet individuals, Aleksey Petukhov and Rostislav Shapovalov, to pressure him to return to Russia. The two were studying English at Columbia University in the same class as Kashtanov, and Shapovalov was a diplomat at the Soviet Mission to the UN delegates, and Petukhov was employed in the United Nations secretariat in New York. Kashtanov stated that in April 1956, both had approached him asking why he had taken an anti-Soviet tone in his writings, claiming that the U.S. political position on the Soviet Union would fail and it would be better for Soviet emigres if they supported the Soviet side. The Soviet officers were aware of Kashtanov’s true identity and his affiliation with Vlasov’s Army during the war.[xxi] Kashtanov’s account of the Soviets’ pressuring him was later broadcast into the Soviet Union by Radio Liberation. The event came just a few weeks after the redefection of five Soviet merchant marines from the oil tanker Tuapse, who had jumped ship in Taiwan and were brought to the United States, but soon returned to the Soviet Union. Kashtanov’s story was a direct counter to Soviet propaganda stating that the Tuapse seamen had voluntarily returned. Shapovalov was expelled from the United States in September.[xxii]
He became a vocal anti-Soviet commentator, and in 1973, he was among the founding members of Congress of Russian Americans, which advocated for Russian refugee and immigration causes. Kashtanov died in October 1980 in New York.[xxiii]
Notes
- [i] He spelled his name Michael Schatoff after his immigration to the United States
- [ii] Evgeniy Aleksandrovich Aleksandrov, Русские в Северной Америке: Биографический Словарь (Russians in North America: A Biographical Dictionary), (Hamden, CT; San Francisco; St. Petersburg: Congress of Russian Americans, 2005), p. 565.
- [iii] Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 4, Case 220 (interviewer J.B.), p. 1.
- [iv] Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 2, Case 220 (interviewer S.H.), p. 1.
- [v] Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 2, Case 220 (interviewer H.D.), p. 3.
- [vi] Letter from Kashtanov to Nikolaevsky, dated 25 August 1949, Hoover Institution Archive, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 501, folder 1 (microfilm reel 290). He similarly describe this event in a Harvard Project interview but provided more detail; see Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 2, Case 220 (interviewer H.D.), pp. 3-4. In his letter to Nikolaevsky he stated that the event occurred in 1933, but in his Harvard Project interview he placed it as occurring when he was 14 years old.
- [vii] Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 4, Case 220 (interviewer J.B.), pp. 1-9.
- [viii] Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 2, Case 220 (interviewer S.H.), p. 3.
- [ix] Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System. Schedule B, Vol. 2, Case 220 (interviewer S.H.), p. 4.
- [x] Dmitriy Aleksandrovich Zhukov and Ivan Ivanovich Kovtun, РННА: Враг в Советской Форме (RNNA: Enemy in a Soviet Uniform) (Moscow, Veche, 2012), https://litresp.ru/kniga/ru/%D0%9A/kovtun-ivan-ivanovich/rnna-vrag-v-sovetskoj-forme.
- [xi] Konstantin Grigoryevich Kromiadi, За Землю, За Волю: Воспоминания соратника генерала Власова (For Land, For Freedom: Reminiscences of General Vlasov’s Comrade in Arms) (Moscow: Veche, 2011), https://litmir.club/bd/?b=242395. See also Kirill Mikhailovich Aleksandrov, Офицерский Корпус Армии Генерал-Лейтенанта Ал. Власова, 1944-1945 (Officer Corps of the Army of General Lieutenant Vlasov, 1944-1945) (Saint Petersburg: Русско-Балтийский информационный центр, «БЛИЦ», 2001), p. 324.
- [xii] Kromiadi, For Land, For Freedom.
- [xiii] Letters from Kashtanov to Nikolaevsky, dated 22 February 1950 and 2 May 1950, Hoover Institution Archive, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 501, folder 1 (microfilm reel 290).
- [xiv] Vladimir Rindin (pseudonym for Kashtanov), От Р.Н.Н.А. к Р.О.А. (From the RNNA to the ROA), pp. 6-7, Hoover Institution Archive, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 408, folder 10 (microfilm number 295).
- [xv] Michael Schatoff, Библиография Освободительного Движения Народов России в Годы Второй Мировой Войны, 1941-1945 (Bibliography on the Vlassov Movement in World War II, 1941-1945) (New York: All-Slavic Publishing House, 1961).
- [xvi] Letter from Nikolaevsky to Kashtanov dated, 4 August 1949, Hoover Institution Archive, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 501, folder 1 (microfilm reel 290).
- [xvii] David J. Dallin and Boris I. Nikolаevsky, Forced Labor in Soviet Russia (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1947).
- [xviii] A manuscript of the book is in the Hoover Institution Archive, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 408, folder 9 (microfilm number 295). A manuscript copy is also in the Columbia University Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Research Program of the USSR Manuscripts, Box 40.
- [xix] Michael Schatoff, “Sketches on the Operations of the NKVD” (title is handwritten, with the original title, НКВД и Его Нити, blackened out), Columbia University Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Research Program of the USSR Manuscripts, Box 40.
- [xx] Letter from Nikolaevsky to Kashtanov, dated 25 March 1950, Hoover Institution Archive, Boris Nicolaevsky Collection, Box 501, folder 1 (microfilm reel 290).
- [xxi] U.S. Congress. Senate, Committee on the Judiciary, Subcommittee to Investigate the Administration of the Internal Security Act and Other Internal Security Laws, Scope of Soviet Activity in the United States, 84th Congress, Second Session, 13 and 20 June 1956 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1956), pp. 1364-1368, 1375-1383.
- [xxii] “Red Departs, Still Assailing before Sailing,” Daily News (New York), 13 September 1956, p. 10.
- [xxiii] Aleksandrov, Russians in North America, p. 565.