Biography
Little firm information is available about the personal history of Aleksandr Grigoryevich Kopatskiy,[i] more commonly known as Igor Grigoryevich Orlov. Information about Kopatskiy comes from three main sources, all of which were published a decade of more after Kopatskiy’s death: interviews with his wife, Eleonore Orlov, by journalist David Wise in the early 1990s[ii]; the personal memories of U.S. CIA officers involved in handling him, published in 1999[iii]; and Soviet archival materials unofficially gathered by Soviet intelligence officer defector Vasiliy Mitrokhin, also published in 1999.[iv] These sources differ on a number of points and little information from Kopatskiy himself or from officially released U.S. or Soviet archival documents is available. When Murphy, Kondrashev, and Bailey requested information from Soviet archives about Orlov/Kopatskiy in preparation for their 1999 book, they received an answer that Soviet archives contained no references to such a person prior to 1965 when he walked into the Soviet embassy in Washington, DC.[v]
Sources provide three different birthdates and places for Kopatskiy: 1 January 1922 in Kiev,[vi] in 1923 in the Bryansk Oblast,[vii] and in 1924 in Kiev.[viii] The two Kiev references are derived from Kopatskiy’s own accounts given to his American supervisors and to his wife. The 1923 birthdate is from Mitrokhin’s notes, which are derived from Kopatskiy’s Soviet file.
His real name is also a matter of debate. Murphy, Kondrashev, and Bailey write that his name was originally Igor Grigoryevich Orlov, and that he received papers with the name Aleksandr Grigoryevich Kopatskiy when he joined the KONR in 1945. He supposedly gained the nickname “Sasha” from this latter pseudonym. Mitrokin refers to him by the name Kopatskiy, with Orlov being his assumed name.[ix] His wife recounted that he had assumed the name Kopatskiy after he arrived in Germany, thinking that a Polish-sounding name would save him from repatriation; the name Orlov came even later. He never told his wife his real name, but she recalls that he may have listed his parents' surname as Navratilov on a form.[x]
Sources are consistent in stating that he entered the Soviet Army for training in Novosibirsk as an intelligence officer in August 1941, when he was only 17-19 years old. His training included the skills needed to conduct partisan operations behind German lines,[xi] probably similar to that of other intelligence officer defectors, such as Yesenina, Dubkov, Granovskiy, Baklanov, and Khokhlov.
The length of his training and when he first began operating behind German lines are not known. However, it is generally established that he was parachuted into German-held territory in October or December 1943 to conduct partisan operations.[xii] This operation did not last long, because he was wounded and sent to a German hospital, where he recuperated for several months. By April 1944, he had been recruited as a Nazi intelligence officer, and in 1945, he joined the KONR to work in the intelligence section.[xiii] He may have used yet another name in the KONR, because Aleksandrov does not list any of Kopatskiy’s various names among the KONR intelligence section officers.[xiv]
Some have surmised that Kopatskiy was dropped into German territory as a false defector with a mission to penetrate German intelligence.[xv] However, Kopatskiy was more likely a legitimate, but reluctant defector. Aleksandrov notes that he was among a few officers within the KONR military forces who were known for retaining their Soviet patriotism even after joining the KONR. These officers’ attitudes were motivated less by anti-Stalinism than by anti-Nazism, and they hoped to return someday to the Soviet Union to “atone for their sins to the Motherland.”[xvi] Expressing pro-Soviet views and aspirations would be incompatible with the objectives of a dispatched defector, who would rather have avoided drawing attention to himself to reduce the risk of German counterintelligence scrutiny.
Kopatskiy was in a U.S.-run POW camp after the war and came to the attention of the Central Intelligence Group (CIG), the post-war predecessor to the CIA, as early as 1946. He became involved with the anti-Soviet émigré organization, Союз Борьбы за Освобождение Народов России (Struggle for the Liberation of the Peoples of Russia; SBONR), which was for a time sponsored by the CIG/CIA, and from there he was hired as an agent recruiter. In 1949, the CIA moved him and his wife, whom he married in 1947, to West Berlin, where his primary mission was to recruit German prostitutes to get close to Soviet military personnel in East Berlin, hopefully enticing them to defect in what were known as REDCAP operations. He operated in Berlin under the name Franz Koischwitz.
In line with his wartime expressions of continued affinity toward the Soviet Union, Mitrokhin’s notes indicate that Kopatskiy walked into the Soviet Military Mission in Baden-Baden, Germany, and offered his services in 1949. Mitrokhin indicates that it was at that time that he infiltrated the SBONR under Soviet orders; however, he may have already been involved with the organization under CIG/CIA sponsorship and began reporting to Soviet intelligence about the organization’s workings and personnel at that time.[xvii]
About the time Kopatskiy moved to Berlin, one of his colleagues and fellow ex-SBONR members, Vladimir Kivi, disappeared from Munich. Although the police found no trace of him, it was assumed that he had been kidnapped. Mitrokhin’s notes indicate that Kopatskiy had provided Soviet intelligence with information about Kivi’s whereabouts, got him drunk, and transported him to East Berlin, where he was taken into Soviet custody.[xviii] No suspicion was cast on Kopatskiy at the time, however.[xix]
Kopatskiy and his wife were transferred to the United States in 1957, and he continued to work for the CIA until 1960, when he was released and took a job driving a newspaper delivery truck. Kopatskiy soon became one of the most controversial defectors in the history of the CIA after KGB defector Anatoliy Golitsyn provided a partial description of a CIA employee nicknamed “Sasha,” who was of Slavic origin and whose real name began with a "K," and who had been recruited by Soviet intelligence. This lead set off a flurry of activity within the CIA and eventually the FBI to identify a Soviet mole; the search for “Sasha” led to a paralyzing internal investigation that damaged the careers of several officers before suspicion eventually fell upon Kopatskiy. His name and career fit the description of the spy that Golitsyn described, and several anomalies involving cases he had run in Germany, as well as the disappearance of Kivi, lent credence to the suspicions. However, after several years of investigation the FBI never uncovered sufficient information to prosecute him for espionage. Some CIA officials, led by James Angleton, were convinced of his guilt, but others questioned it. Wise quotes one former CIA official as saying, “We did not think he had ever been under the control of the KGB. My overall impression is we didn't have a case against Orlov. A lot of suspicions, but no case.”[xx] No specific allegations against him surfaced until Mitrokhin’s notes came to light in the 1990s.
Kopatskiy and his wife opened an art gallery in Alexandria, Virginia, outside Washington, DC, known as Gallery Orlov. After over a year of FBI investigations, interviews, and raids on his gallery, Kopatskiy walked into the Soviet embassy in Washington, DC, in 1965 and requested asylum. He was prepared to go back to the Soviet Union; however, his wife, who was German and had never lived in Russia, refused to go. He continued to live and work in Virginia until his death in May 1982. The FBI investigated him for over 15 years, but never brought a case against him.
Sources provide three different birthdates and places for Kopatskiy: 1 January 1922 in Kiev,[vi] in 1923 in the Bryansk Oblast,[vii] and in 1924 in Kiev.[viii] The two Kiev references are derived from Kopatskiy’s own accounts given to his American supervisors and to his wife. The 1923 birthdate is from Mitrokhin’s notes, which are derived from Kopatskiy’s Soviet file.
His real name is also a matter of debate. Murphy, Kondrashev, and Bailey write that his name was originally Igor Grigoryevich Orlov, and that he received papers with the name Aleksandr Grigoryevich Kopatskiy when he joined the KONR in 1945. He supposedly gained the nickname “Sasha” from this latter pseudonym. Mitrokin refers to him by the name Kopatskiy, with Orlov being his assumed name.[ix] His wife recounted that he had assumed the name Kopatskiy after he arrived in Germany, thinking that a Polish-sounding name would save him from repatriation; the name Orlov came even later. He never told his wife his real name, but she recalls that he may have listed his parents' surname as Navratilov on a form.[x]
Sources are consistent in stating that he entered the Soviet Army for training in Novosibirsk as an intelligence officer in August 1941, when he was only 17-19 years old. His training included the skills needed to conduct partisan operations behind German lines,[xi] probably similar to that of other intelligence officer defectors, such as Yesenina, Dubkov, Granovskiy, Baklanov, and Khokhlov.
The length of his training and when he first began operating behind German lines are not known. However, it is generally established that he was parachuted into German-held territory in October or December 1943 to conduct partisan operations.[xii] This operation did not last long, because he was wounded and sent to a German hospital, where he recuperated for several months. By April 1944, he had been recruited as a Nazi intelligence officer, and in 1945, he joined the KONR to work in the intelligence section.[xiii] He may have used yet another name in the KONR, because Aleksandrov does not list any of Kopatskiy’s various names among the KONR intelligence section officers.[xiv]
Some have surmised that Kopatskiy was dropped into German territory as a false defector with a mission to penetrate German intelligence.[xv] However, Kopatskiy was more likely a legitimate, but reluctant defector. Aleksandrov notes that he was among a few officers within the KONR military forces who were known for retaining their Soviet patriotism even after joining the KONR. These officers’ attitudes were motivated less by anti-Stalinism than by anti-Nazism, and they hoped to return someday to the Soviet Union to “atone for their sins to the Motherland.”[xvi] Expressing pro-Soviet views and aspirations would be incompatible with the objectives of a dispatched defector, who would rather have avoided drawing attention to himself to reduce the risk of German counterintelligence scrutiny.
Kopatskiy was in a U.S.-run POW camp after the war and came to the attention of the Central Intelligence Group (CIG), the post-war predecessor to the CIA, as early as 1946. He became involved with the anti-Soviet émigré organization, Союз Борьбы за Освобождение Народов России (Struggle for the Liberation of the Peoples of Russia; SBONR), which was for a time sponsored by the CIG/CIA, and from there he was hired as an agent recruiter. In 1949, the CIA moved him and his wife, whom he married in 1947, to West Berlin, where his primary mission was to recruit German prostitutes to get close to Soviet military personnel in East Berlin, hopefully enticing them to defect in what were known as REDCAP operations. He operated in Berlin under the name Franz Koischwitz.
In line with his wartime expressions of continued affinity toward the Soviet Union, Mitrokhin’s notes indicate that Kopatskiy walked into the Soviet Military Mission in Baden-Baden, Germany, and offered his services in 1949. Mitrokhin indicates that it was at that time that he infiltrated the SBONR under Soviet orders; however, he may have already been involved with the organization under CIG/CIA sponsorship and began reporting to Soviet intelligence about the organization’s workings and personnel at that time.[xvii]
About the time Kopatskiy moved to Berlin, one of his colleagues and fellow ex-SBONR members, Vladimir Kivi, disappeared from Munich. Although the police found no trace of him, it was assumed that he had been kidnapped. Mitrokhin’s notes indicate that Kopatskiy had provided Soviet intelligence with information about Kivi’s whereabouts, got him drunk, and transported him to East Berlin, where he was taken into Soviet custody.[xviii] No suspicion was cast on Kopatskiy at the time, however.[xix]
Kopatskiy and his wife were transferred to the United States in 1957, and he continued to work for the CIA until 1960, when he was released and took a job driving a newspaper delivery truck. Kopatskiy soon became one of the most controversial defectors in the history of the CIA after KGB defector Anatoliy Golitsyn provided a partial description of a CIA employee nicknamed “Sasha,” who was of Slavic origin and whose real name began with a "K," and who had been recruited by Soviet intelligence. This lead set off a flurry of activity within the CIA and eventually the FBI to identify a Soviet mole; the search for “Sasha” led to a paralyzing internal investigation that damaged the careers of several officers before suspicion eventually fell upon Kopatskiy. His name and career fit the description of the spy that Golitsyn described, and several anomalies involving cases he had run in Germany, as well as the disappearance of Kivi, lent credence to the suspicions. However, after several years of investigation the FBI never uncovered sufficient information to prosecute him for espionage. Some CIA officials, led by James Angleton, were convinced of his guilt, but others questioned it. Wise quotes one former CIA official as saying, “We did not think he had ever been under the control of the KGB. My overall impression is we didn't have a case against Orlov. A lot of suspicions, but no case.”[xx] No specific allegations against him surfaced until Mitrokhin’s notes came to light in the 1990s.
Kopatskiy and his wife opened an art gallery in Alexandria, Virginia, outside Washington, DC, known as Gallery Orlov. After over a year of FBI investigations, interviews, and raids on his gallery, Kopatskiy walked into the Soviet embassy in Washington, DC, in 1965 and requested asylum. He was prepared to go back to the Soviet Union; however, his wife, who was German and had never lived in Russia, refused to go. He continued to live and work in Virginia until his death in May 1982. The FBI investigated him for over 15 years, but never brought a case against him.
Notes
- [i] This surname is usually transliterated in English as Kopatzky.
- [ii] David Wise, Molehunt: The Secret Search for Traitors That Shattered the CIA (New York: Random House, 1992), pp. 180-199, 271-282.
- [iii] David E. Murphy, Sergei A. Kondrashev, and George Bailey, Battleground Berlin: CIA vs. KGB in the Cold War (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999), pp. 110-112, 240-248.
- [iv] Christopher Andrew and Vasili Mitrokhin, The Sword and the Shield: The Mitrokhin Archive and the Secret History of the KGB (New York: Basic Books, 1999), pp. 148-149, 176-177.
- [v] Murphy, Kondrashev, and Bailey, Battleground Berlin, p. 148. Photo between pp. 134 and 135.
- [vi] David Wise, Molehunt, p. 184.
- [vii] Andrew and Mitrokhin, The Sword and the Shield, p. 149. Mitrokhin notes that the only information in Kopatskiy/Orlov’s file prior to 1946 is his birthdate and place; see p. 602, n75.
- [viii] Murphy, Kondrashev, and Bailey, Battleground Berlin, p. 110.
- [ix] Andrew and Mitrokhin, The Sword and the Shield, p. 602, n79.
- [x] David Wise, Molehunt, p. 183.
- [xi] Murphy, Kondrashev, George Bailey, Battleground Berlin, p. 111.
- [xii] Murphy, Kondrashev, and Bailey say October, p. 111; Andrew and Mitrokhin (p. 149) and Wise (p. 184) say December.
- [xiii] Andrew and Mitrokhin, The Sword and the Shield, p. 149.
- [xiv] A list of the KONR intelligence staff is listed in Kirill Mikhailovich Aleksandrov, Генералитет и Офицерские Кадры Вооруженных Формирований Комитета Освобождения Народов России 1943–1946 гг. (General and Officer Corps of the Armed Formations of the Committee for the Liberation of the Peoples of Russia 1943-1946), dissertation for the Russian Academy of Sciences, Saint Petersburg History Institute, 2015, p, 994.
- [xv] James Angleton, CIA Chief of Counterintelligence from 1954 to 1975, was among these; see Wise, Molehunt, p. 273.
- [xvi] Kirill Mikhailovich Aleksandrov, General and Officer Corps of the Armed Formations of the Committee for the Liberation of the Peoples of Russia 1943-1946, pp, 628-629.
- [xvii] Andrew and Mitrokhin, The Sword and the Shield, p. 149.
- [xviii] Andrew and Mitrokhin, The Sword and the Shield, p. 149.
- [xix] Murphy, Kondrashev, George Bailey, Battleground Berlin, p. 241.
- [xx] Wise, Molehunt, p. 197....